Fly Fishing New Mexico: An Angler’s Guide

An expert angler's guide to fly fishing New Mexico including the best spots, flies to use, technique & approaches for all the fish you'll find in the state.

Fly fishing New Mexico combines the best of the West with the best of the South. You’ll find warm temperatures and desert ecosystems all over the state, but still have ample access to seclusion in beautiful mountains.

This is one of the country’s best fly fishing destinations. The scenery, water, and fish is plentiful and varied enough to satisfy even the most demanding fly anglers.

The best part of New Mexico fly fishing is that all of these areas are filled with beautiful waters that have large, strong-fighting fish lurking beneath the surface. Combine your fly fishing with mountain biking, climbing, and backpacking and you’ll experience outdoor greatness.

Fly Fishing New Mexico Man Walks Down Path

On our annual family trip to Arizona, we’d always stop in New Mexico to fly fish. We often seemed to be the only ones on the water. The fish were always willing to eat, and New Mexico became one of our best-kept secrets.

Until now, that is. With this article about New Mexico fly fishing, I’ll share all my secrets and what I’ve learned during the many times I’ve visited the state. In my camper van with my family along for the ride, I’ve crossed the desert, bumped through the mountains, and hooked into some truly beautiful fish in the rivers and lakes of New Mexico.

Disclaimer: IntoFlyFishing.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, as an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Please see our Privacy Page for more information.

Why Go Fly Fishing in New Mexico?

New Mexico isn’t a place many anglers choose to fish. While it receives a fair amount of pressure from locals, this state provides a variety of unique lakes and rivers for people to experience. Until you visit, you won’t realize how impressive of a state it is.

What to Pack for Fly Fishing New Mexico

Here are a few of the essential items for any fly fishing trip. All of these have come in handy in New Mexico when I went there to fly fish, as there are so many different styles of fishing in the state.

  • Your best fly rod overall: Bring your favorite rod overall as well as the ones listed below if you have them in your kit.
  • A 3 weight fly rod: For smaller trout species
  • A 5 weight fly rod: For medium sized fish
  • A 7 weight fly rod: Versatile and good for larger fish
  • An 8 weight fly rod: Good for most of the biggest fish you’ll catch in New Mexico
  • Your best fly reel overall: A decent matching weight reel and good fly line is important. Bring a reel to match each rod.
  • A fly fishing pack: Whether it’s a sling or a backpack, these are good for packing even more gear.
  • A fly fishing vest: Pack your leader, line, nippers, and flies close to your chest.
  • A fly fishing combo set: You can pick up a combo kit that comes with all (or most) of the above.
  • Fly fishing waders: Ideal to get into those difficult spots in the river
  • Best wading boots: Keep the feet on your waders protected from sharp rocks.
  • Fly fishing sunglasses: A good polarized pair of lenses to remove the glare from the water and protect your eyes from UV rays
  • Fly fishing net: Get a rubber net to protect the fish. Make sure it’s large enough to land good-sized fish.
  • A fly box: Bring your best waterproof fly box to keep your flies safe and dry while fishing in New Mexico.
  • Flies: Western March Browns, BWOs, Blood Midges, Prince Nymphs, Elk Hair Caddis, Pheasant Tail, large baitfish streamers, midge nymphs, Cluster Minnows, Woolly Buggers, and chartreuse color crayfish patterns

New Mexico Fly Fishing Species

While fly fishing New Mexico, I’ve caught five different types of trout as well as landing my fair share of bass and pike. New Mexico’s fish populations are only continuing to grow. You won’t find a shortage of catchable fish, and they’re rarely difficult to land.

Brook Trout

Brook trout are some of the more uncommon trout in New Mexico. They’re found primarily in mountain streams like Caresto Creek and Tecolote Creek. They usually grow to 8 to 10 inches in these creeks.

Brook Trout Fly Fishing New Mexico

Brook trout are often spooky and need to be fished using fluorocarbon tippet. I’ve had good days using Western March Browns, BWOs, and Blood Midges. The smaller patterns you can use, the better chance you have to catch these brookies.

Brown Trout

New Mexico holds several wild populations of brown trout, and also these fish are stocked across the state. They can be found up to 5 pounds in some of the lakes and rivers in New Mexico, including the Rio Guadalupe River and the Cimarron River.

Trout Species Fly Fishing in New Mexico

Browns are some of the heartiest trout in the world and can associate with warm-water fish. Therefore, large baitfish streamers like Woolly Buggers, Cluster Minnows, and crayfish patterns work. Prince Nymphs and Elk Hair Caddis also catch New Mexico brown trout.

Gila Trout

Gila trout are one of the native fish species in New Mexico. These golden brown trout have been the subject of many relief efforts. The Gila Trout Recovery Plan was introduced in 2003 to save the species.

Gila Trout Fly Fishing Species in New Mexico

I’ve hooked into Gila trout in the Gila and Aldo Leopold Wilderness Areas. Main Diamond, South Diamond, Whiskey Creek and Spruce Creek all hold native Gila trout. Also, Black Canyon, Willow Creek, and Mineral Creek hold these fish.

To catch them, I’ve used small Pheasant Tail and Prince Nymphs. Also, WD-40 flies are a great option. Bring 5 or 6x fluorocarbon tippet. Gila trout are spooky and need to be handled with care.

Rainbow Trout

Rainbow trout are the most heavily stocked trout in New Mexico. The Red River, San Juan River, and Cimarron River are filled with these fish. They can be found upwards of 5 or 6 pounds throughout New Mexico.

Rainbow Trout Species for Fly Fishing

I’ve landed some of the bigger fish with large baitfish streamers. However, BWOs and Adams are great to use for dry flies. These fish love to surface feed during the hatches.

Rio Grande Cutthroat Trout

The Rio Grande cutthroat trout is the second native trout species in New Mexico. Plus, it’s considered to be the state fish. These are mostly found in the high headwaters in northern New Mexico.

You’ll catch them in the Rio Grande, Pecos, and Canadian rivers. They’re extremely rare, but are considered to be one of the most beautiful trout in the world. If you’re targeting these, use barbless hooks to ensure their full recovery.

Use small midge nymphs, Pheasant Tails, and Elk Hair Caddis flies to catch Rio Grande cutthroat trout. I’ve mainly fished for them in pocket water. If you do too, be prepared to be accurate with your casts.

Bass

Bass are found all over New Mexico. They most often live in the lakes throughout the state, including the Abiquiu Reservoir, Brantley Lake and Navajo Lake.

Fly Fishing in New Mexico for Largemouth Bass

In my experience, an 8-weight is the right rod to handle these fish. I use 1 or 2x leader with Gutless Frogs and Popper flies, and I’ve had success with Cluster Minnows and Woolly Buggers as well.

Pike

Pike are a more recent addition to New Mexico. The Game and Fish Department started stocking them in the 1970s. I’ve found them in the Rio Grande Gorge, Elephant Butte Reservoir, and Conchas Reservoir.

They can reach upwards of 30 inches. Chartreuse color crayfish patterns and Woolly Buggers are great choices. The more action with these, the better. Remember your 8-weight and 0x leader. They’ll snap you off if they have the chance.

Best Spots for Fly Fishing New Mexico

There’s no shortage of variety when it comes to fishable water in New Mexico. I’ve fished alpine streams and lakes as well as wide flowing rivers. Depending on your preference, New Mexico will fulfill your needs.

Fly Fishing Rivers in New Mexico

New Mexico is world famous for the San Juan River. This is a wide flowing river that requires skill to fish. There are also numerous small mountain streams with wild populations of trout.

San Juan River

?Directions: San Juan River, NM

Let’s start with the San Juan. This river is an absolute must for anyone visiting New Mexico. In fact, it was the first spot I hit on my first trip to the state.

On average, anglers catch rainbow and brown trout around 17 inches. If you can find them, you’ll be in great shape. Some experts say there are over 7,000 fish per mile.

Aerial Photo - Fly Fishing on The San Juan River in New Mexico
Fly Fishing the San Juan River in New Mexico

You can find plenty of access to both wade and drift. If possible, drift this water. There are too many beautiful spots to visit that you can’t reach while wading.

Use your 6-weight to handle the power of these fish. Also, 3 or 4x leader with 5x fluorocarbon tippet is necessary. These fish are pressured, so they need realistic looking presentations.

The Game and Fish Department requires you to use barbless hooks. Pheasant Tails, WD-40s, Jujubee Midge, Zebra Midges and Sidewinder Midges are all great options to use on the San Juan. Don’t pass on an opportunity to fish the river!

Red River

?Directions: Red River, NM

The Red River flows out of the Rio Grande River and is filled with rainbow, cutthroat and brown trout. This river is broken into the upper and lower sections. The upper section is easier to fish with more access. You can find this above the town of Red River.

The lower Red River starts below the town of Questa. When I visited, I had to hike in a canyon to reach the best portions of water. However, its beauty and less pressured fish made it well worth the extra effort.

Bring your 5 or 6-weight with lighter tippet. The terrestrial fly hatch in the late summer is a must for any fly angler. Also, Little Yellow Stoneflies and BWOs are great options.

Gila River

?Directions: Gila River, NM

The Gila River is a diverse fishery with a variety of options for anglers. You’ll find rainbow trout, smallmouth bass, and carp. The upper portion of the Gila is located at around 7,000 feet, so you’ll find better trout fishing here.

Hiking into the Gila River for fly fishing New Mexico

In the upper portion, use stoneflies, midges, and caddis flies. They’ll all catch fish, especially during the hatches. If you’re fishing for trout, you can use your 4-weight with 5x tippet.

The East Fork is home to a smallmouth bass population. These are best caught on minnow and crayfish flies. If you’re targeting smallmouth, bring your 7 or 8-weight. It’s no secret that these fish are some of the best fighters around.

Pecos River

?Directions: Pecos River, NM

The Pecos River is located on national forest land, so access is plentiful. Much of Highway 63 follows the river, allowing for ample opportunities to the numerous appealing holes.

Pecos River new mexico

I’ve found rainbow and brown trout in the Pecos. The Upper Pecos has populations of Gila trout in its far reaches. Use your stoneflies and salmon flies. Also, small nymphs and Woolly Buggers can get the larger fish out of the pools.

Bring your 3 weight fly rod or a 4 weight fly rod to the Pecos. The water requires more technical casting, and you’ll want as much finesse as you can manage. It’s a beautiful river located amongst tall ponderosa pines. You can’t go wrong with a day on the Pecos!

Rio Chama River: El Vado Tailwater

?Directions: Rio Chama River, NM

The Rio Chama only flows through six miles of New Mexico. Most it flows through southern Colorado. However, the New Mexico record brown trout was pulled from the Rio Chama, so it’s well worth fishing.

Rio Chama River new mexico

I’ve had success with caddis, midges, and mayflies, fishing pools, riffles, and pocket water. The runoff can greatly affect the quality of the Rio Chama fishing, but it always stays fairly consistent.

Due to the large fish, you’ll want to use your 6 or 7-weight rod. Bring 3x leader with 4x tippet. You can also catch fish on Woolly Buggers and crayfish patterns. The larger fish won’t hesitate to eat the large flies.

Fly Fishing Lakes in New Mexico

You can fish both high and low elevation lakes in New Mexico. Many have healthy populations of trout as well as bass and northern pike. You aren’t ever too far away from a lake in New Mexico, despite what the landscape may present.

Santa Cruz Lake

?Directions: Santa Cruz Lake, NM

New Mexico’s record rainbow trout was pulled out of Santa Cruz Lake. Weighing in at over 30 pounds, it was a good indicator of the massive fish this lake holds. Plus, it’s right outside of Santa Fe, so it’s easily accessible.

Bank fishing is a great choice for Santa Cruz Lake. There are trails that take you all around the shore. It’s best to do a bit of wading when fishing the Santa Cruz. You’ll need the room for casting. The banks have cover that can make it difficult to find angles.

If you do have a boat, it’s only allowed to be used at trolling speeds.

Bring your 6 or 7-weight to handle some of these fish.  Also, minnow patterns, midges, and Woolly Buggers work well. These are stocked fish so they won’t be as picky with your fly choice. Whatever you throw, present it naturally and you’re good to go.

Fenton Lake

?Directions: Fenton Lake, NM

Located in Fenton Lake State Park, Fenton Lake is a beautiful body of water surrounded by forests. As a result, you’ll need to do some wade fishing. If you have a canoe or kayak, Fenton Lake is a great place to bring it.

Fenton Lake in New Mexico

There are several campgrounds that surround the lake, so you can make it your home base as you explore the surrounding areas. It’s stocked with rainbow trout all year long and these fish are always willing to eat.

Deceiver flies, crayfish patterns and Woolly Buggers will work. The Jemez River is located near Fenton Lake, so if you want something besides still water you can give it a try.

Bring your family for a few days and experience the beauty of Fenton Lake State Park.

Whiskey Lake

?Directions: Whiskey Lake, NM

Whiskey Lake is located on the east side of New Mexico near Gallup. The stocked rainbow trout fill the waters and can grow up to 24 inches.

This lake is located on the Navajo Reservation, so you’ll need a special permit to fish the lake. You can find the permit at all of the sporting goods stores in Gallup.

Bring your 6-weight along with a variety of flies to Whiskey Lake. Muddler Minnows, Tungsten Jig Buggers and Sculpin Streamers all work well in Whiskey Lake.

This is a unique fishery that can be fished either on the banks or via a small boat. I found the bank fishing to be tough due to the surrounding vegetation, but if you’re willing to wade, you’ll be just fine.

Eagle Nest Lake

?Directions: Eagle Nest Lake, NM

Eagle Nest Lake in Northeast New Mexico provides some of the best Kokanee salmon and trout fishing in the state. It’s located at over 8,000 feet of elevation. Located in Eagle Nest State Park, this is a great place to bring the family.

Eagle Nest Lake New Mexico

You should fish Eagle Nest Lake from the bank. You can wade in the refreshing water and have a field day landing some of the larger trout that live in the lake. Bring your caddis and gnat patterns to the lake. By the time night falls, the fish rise.

Also, you won’t need anything more than your 6-weight to land the fish in Eagle Nest Lake. They’re regularly stocked and willing to eat almost everything you throw their way.

Heron Lake

?Directions: Heron Lake, NM

Heron Lake is a 6,000-acre expanse that offers the peace and quiet many anglers desire. The Game and Fish Department allows no wake on the entire lake. There are Kokanee salmon as well as massive lake trout available to be caught.

To catch a lake trout, you’ll need sinking line. These fish sit very close to the bottom in the deepest portions of the lake. As a result, you’ll want to fish this lake from a kayak or canoe.

Bring your 7-weight fly rod to handle these fish and be sure your reel is equipped with 0 or 1x leader. Large baitfish streamers are great to use. Let these sink to the bottom and start stripping. The fish will hit on the drift down or your retrieve.

Bring your family and enjoy a nice, relaxing day in north-central New Mexico.

New Mexico Fishing Season

The official fishing season in New Mexico begins on April 1st, but you can fish the majority of the above-mentioned waters year round. Besides some of the higher elevation lakes (Eagle Nest), the water won’t freeze and you can enjoy fishing throughout the year.

New Mexico Fly Fishing Season - Aerial View
Man Fly Fishing New Mexico Drone View

Be aware that many of the rivers listed above are affected by the runoff each year. During the runoff months, it may not be a bad idea to fish the lakes!

Fly Fishing in April

In April, the runoff has yet to start and fishing is phenomenal. You’ll want to wear waders and warmer clothes because the higher elevation waters are cold.

San Juan Worms, midges, BWOs and black fly patterns all work in April. The fish are enjoying the warmer air temperatures so they’re ready to eat. It’s also never a bad idea to throw a streamer throughout the day to see if the big fish are hungry.

Fly Fishing in May

In May, the runoff begins in New Mexico. The fish are still willing to eat, but they’re likely pushed up against the banks and more difficult to catch. Be patient during May and try fishing some of the listed lakes.

Annelids, leeches, black flies, and scuds are all hatching in May. Also, BWOs begin to show up. These are great to throw all throughout the month.

Fly Fishing in June

By June, the runoff has begun to subside and the waters become more fishable. The fish are back to their normal eating habits and willing to strike the majority of what you throw their way.

Use scuds, BWOs, and stoneflies, and begin to look for the caddis patterns. These are all great options for fly fishing New Mexico in June.

Fly Fishing in July

I always head to the mountains in July in New Mexico. At lower elevations, the temperatures are far too warm and the mountains provide some relief. Start to throw stoneflies, PMDs, and BWOs.

Man on River in New Mexico Fly Fishing in July

Also, the terrestrial hatch is in full swing by mid to late July. Don’t be shy and be willing to throw these flies up against the banks. They’ll lead to some amazing strikes!

Fly Fishing in August

Similar to July, fly fishing New Mexico in August is best done in the mountains. You’ll find hungry fish looking for the terrestrials. I love using dry flies and August in New Mexico is the time to throw them.

Beetles, ants, and hoppers are all making regular appearances on the water. Take advantage of the terrestrial hatches!

Fly Fishing in September

By September, the temperatures across the state begin to cool. However, the terrestrial bite still has a few weeks of life. Keep in the mountains and throw these flies.

It’s also smart to begin using streamers in September. The fish are more aggressive and starting to fatten up for the winter months.

Fishing in October

By October, the mountains will begin to receive snow, and fishing begins to slow. Throw nymphs through the seams and pocket water. The fish aren’t looking to bust the surface or attack heavy streamers.

Best Fly Fishing Lodges in New Mexico

New Mexico has ample options for fly fishing lodges. The vast amount of fishable water makes it a wonderful place to hire a guide and learn the ways of these legendary rivers.

Fly Fishing Lodges in New Mexico

Rainbow Lodge

Located on the San Juan, the Rainbow Lodge has seven miles of wonderful access to this river. There are guided trips available as well as lovely accommodations. A fully inclusive trip for two nights and one day is $960 a person.

VIEW LODGE ON TRIPADVISOR

Soaring Eagle Lodge

The Soaring Eagle is also located on the San Juan River near the Crow’s Foot section. You can purchase an all-inclusive package for around $700 per angler for two nights and one day.

VIEW LODGE ON TRIPADVISOR

Corkins Lodge

Corkins Lodge can be found on the Brazos River. This resort provides 2.5 miles of private access to the Brazos as well as a private trout-stocked pond. You’ll receive guided trips from the Land of Enchantment Guide Service. A cabin will cost you around $400 per night and the guided trips are an added cost.

VIEW LODGE ON TRIPADVISOR

Conclusion

Anglers need to try fly fishing in New Mexico. The waters are worth the trip. You may not ever fish New Mexico unless you make a conscious effort to visit. It’s a perfect place for families and anglers of all skill levels.

On my many trips to the state, I found all of the seclusion that I could ever need in New Mexico. Plus, the size of fish has kept me coming back year after year.

Take it from me, New Mexico deserves to be on any angler’s list of dream fly fishing destinations. Check it out and you’ll see.

Some images in this post are courtesy of Shutterstock.com.

Like This Article? Pin It!

Fly Fishing New Mexico: An Angler's GuideAn Angler’s Guide To Fly Fishing in New Mexico

SHARE THIS POST

Disclaimer: IntoFlyFishing.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, as an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Please see our Privacy Page for more information.

My name is Danny Mooers and I’ve been fly fishing for five years. As soon as I went to college, I dove headfirst into my obsession for fly angling. Every spare weekend or long break was dedicated to finding fish. I’ve fished all over North America in search of trout, salmon, steelhead and everything in between. I currently write articles for Guide Recommended and Reel Adventure Fishing. Fly angling is one of the most challenging yet rewarding hobbies any person can have. Don’t be afraid to give it a try.  It’s an addicting activity that tests everything from your fine motor skills to your patience, but it’s well worth your time.

You may also like...

Slovakia Brown Trout
A quick round-up of our 2022 year of fly fishing including all the destinations we fished, as well as a bit about what's in store for 2023.
a beautiful lake for fly fishing in Florida
This is an angler's guide to fly fishing in Florida. I covers specie, spots, seasons, fly shops, and more.
fly fishing in maldives
An angler’s guide to fly fishing Maldives. This post covers spots, species, fishing gear to use, and best time to fly fish the Maldives.